The best farmhouse board and batten shutters are decorative pairs sized to suit the window and finished to complement the home’s exterior. The Polaris Homeside 55-inch pair is a straightforward choice for taller windows, while Pontiac Trail’s 55- and 59-inch options offer paintable black shutters and included installation hardware. For shorter windows, consider Polaris Homeside’s 35-inch pair. A raised-panel option is also included as an alternative for buyers who want a different look.
| Product | Best For | Listed Size |
|---|---|---|
| Polaris Homeside Board and Batten | Taller windows, basic mounting choices | 14.5 × 55 inches |
| Pontiac Trail Board and Batten | Paintable finish and supplied hardware | 14.5 × 55 inches |
| Pontiac Trail Board and Batten | A slightly taller shutter option | 14.5 × 59 inches |
| Polaris Homeside Board and Batten | Shorter windows | 14.5 × 35 inches |
| Pontiac Trail Raised Panel | Buyers who prefer a panel design | 14.5 × 31 inches |
Polaris Homeside 55-Inch Board And Batten Shutters
This joined vinyl pair measures 14.5 by 55 inches and is listed for decorative use with window heights of 80 to 82 inches. It has a nominal thickness of up to one inch and comes with two hardware options: plastic spikes or metal screws with color-matching caps.
Best for: Homeowners seeking a simple black farmhouse-style look for taller windows who want a choice of mounting hardware. It was selected for its clear size guidance and included hardware alternatives. These shutters are decorative, so choose another product if you need shutters that close over the window.
Pontiac Trail 55-Inch Board And Batten Shutters
This 14.5-by-55-inch pair has a rustic style intended for farmhouse and beach-inspired exteriors. Cosmos Black is listed as paintable. The product information describes additional sizes and colors, and notes that actual shutter dimensions can vary by up to 0.75 inches. A pair includes plugs, screws, and color-matched caps; drilling is required for screw installation.
Best for: Buyers who want a paintable black finish and a listed set of mounting components. Choose this if customization and included hardware matter. The shutters are nonfunctional and decorative only, and installation requires drilling.
Pontiac Trail 59-Inch Board And Batten Shutters
This pair measures 14.5 by 59 inches and shares the Pontiac Trail board-and-batten styling, paintable Cosmos Black finish, and supplied plugs, screws, and caps. The listed dimensions may vary by up to 0.75 inches, so measure the window and confirm the fit before ordering. Screw mounting requires drilling.
Best for: Buyers comparing the Pontiac Trail design who need a longer listed shutter than the 55-inch version. It was selected to provide a size alternative within the same style and hardware setup. Avoid choosing it based on nominal dimensions alone if your window has limited clearance.
Polaris Homeside 35-Inch Board And Batten Shutters
This 14.5-by-35-inch pair is a shorter option in the Polaris Homeside joined vinyl style. The listing says the shutters are available in various colors, are maintenance-free, and are designed for easy installation. It also specifies two horizontal battens for lengths up to 51 inches; three battens are used on lengths of 55 inches or longer.
Best for: Buyers whose windows call for a shorter decorative shutter while retaining a board-and-batten appearance. It was selected as a compact alternative to the 55- and 59-inch options. The provided details do not specify a window-height range for this size, so check measurements rather than assuming a fit.
Pontiac Trail 31-Inch Raised Panel Shutters
This 14.5-by-31-inch navy pair has a raised-panel design rather than board-and-batten construction. It is included as a style alternative for buyers who want a more formal, simple panel appearance. The shutters are decorative and fasten directly to the house; the listing includes plugs, screws, and caps. Drilling is required for screw installation.
Best for: Buyers who like the Pontiac Trail hardware setup but prefer raised panels over farmhouse battens. This is not the right choice if matching board-and-batten details is essential or if functional shutters are needed.
Buying Guide: How To Choose Farmhouse Shutters
How do you select the right shutter size?
Measure the window opening and compare it with each shutter’s listed height and width. Consider the visual balance of the pair beside the window, and check the manufacturer’s fit guidance where available. Pontiac Trail notes that dimensions may vary by up to 0.75 inches. Polaris lists its 55-inch pair for windows 80 to 82 inches high; do not assume that range applies to other sizes.
Which style suits a farmhouse exterior?
Board-and-batten shutters have a straightforward vertical-plank look that supports rustic and farmhouse exteriors. Choose a raised-panel option only if you prefer that distinct design. Before selecting a finish, compare the shutter color with siding, trim, doors, and other exterior details. Pontiac Trail identifies Cosmos Black as paintable; confirm finish details for any other color or model before planning a repaint.
What should you know about installation?
Check what mounting components come with the pair and whether your preferred method is supported. Polaris describes plastic spikes or metal screws with matching caps. Pontiac Trail lists plugs, screws, and caps and says drilling is required for screws. Follow the product’s installation instructions and verify the mounting surface and measurements before drilling.
Are these shutters functional?
The listed products are decorative, not working shutters that close over a window. They are intended to add exterior style. If your priority is closing shutters for light control or protection, these options do not meet that need based on the supplied product descriptions.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are board-and-batten shutters a good fit for farmhouse homes?
They can complement farmhouse exteriors because their simple vertical-board appearance creates a rustic look. Match the size and color to the window and surrounding trim.
Do these shutters close over the window?
No. The listed products are decorative shutters and do not function as movable window coverings.
Do Pontiac Trail shutters include mounting hardware?
The product details list shutter plugs, screws, and color-matched caps. Screw installation requires drilling.
Which listed option is shortest?
The Pontiac Trail raised-panel alternative is listed at 31 inches tall. Among the board-and-batten options, the Polaris Homeside pair is listed at 35 inches.